로그인 페이지
 
 
내 용
글쓴이 운영자 날짜 2014-01-29
E-mail info@pes21.com 홈페이지 http://www.pes21.com

조회수 : 257519   

제 목 : Comparing Low-Alloy Vs Carbon Steel
Comparing Low-Alloy Vs Carbon Steel in a heat treatment character


1. INTRODUCTION
Generally, Cr-Mo Low-Alloy steel (ASTM A387-Gr.12-Cl.2) is well known for heat
resistant material as elevated temperature(469 oC~537 oC) service in pressure vessel because of its high strength value and resistant of Creep stress in a contents of 1%Cr-1/2%Mo
and it can be free of Hydrogen penetration during welding. However, it should be considering metallurgy character of Cr contents with regard to its weld ability and welding crack. Therefore, all most of welding condition should be required post weld heat treatment as per UCS-56, ASME code, except below thickness 16mm plate.

2. METALLURGY CHARACTER OF Cr-Mo Low-Alloy / CHEMICAL COMPOSITION
1) Easly subject to integranular corrosion due to Cr. Separation from grain boundary of Cr23C16
2) Easly hydrogen gas emission during welding
3) Easly subject to High temperature Crack around 550 oC at cooling time.
When we compare the chemical composition of ASTM A387-Gr11-Cl2 with ASTM A387-11-2 material contains Mo(0.45%) and Cr(1%) against A516-70, However, Mn composition is less than A516-70, Mn have a function to minimize the size of
crystallation, those by, increases the strength, toughness instead of less contents of Carbon And Si composition is similar function to Carbon by up to containing 0.3% regardless of chemical composition.

3. HEAT TREATMENT CHARACTER OF Low-Alloy
As mentioned in introduction, Cr-Mo Low-Alloy material should be heat treatment
considering its metallurgy character as below chart because of 475 oC embrittlement because local stress occurs between grain boundary during heating and cooling time.
Therefore, all most of Cr-Mo Alloy material should be heat treated as method of water cooling in order to avoid 475 oC embrittlement after cooling at Furnace (700oC ~ 750oC) there by, Cr can not be separated from Carbon grain.

4. HEAT TREATMENT PURPOSE 4-1. PRE-HEATING PURPOSE
(1) Stress relieving as minimizing contraction
(2) Avoiding hardening in heat affected zone
(3) Easly hydrogen emission during welding
(4) Preventing lack of fusion
(5) Removing humidity

4-2. POST-HEATING PURPOSE
(1) Increasing toughness in welding area
(2) Re-arrangement of recrystallization boundary for each grain layer
(3) Stress relieving as minimizing contraction
(4) Preventing welding crack
As summarized above, the most of purpose is to prevent welding crack and minimizing local stress after welding.

5. STRESS RELIEVING METHOD
(1) Furnance heat treatment (For Cr-Mo, Low-Alloy, heating to 850 oC, Cooling at ambient)
(2) Local heat treatment (Not recommended method)
(3) Stress relieving at Low temperature
(4) Stress relieving by Mechanical method
(5) Peening

6. HEAT TREATMENT METALLURGY REVIEW
When we review that Industrial practice and related CODE requirement such as ASME and BS, JIS , they regulated heat treatment requirements as similar basis but can not be covered whole of metallurgy condition. For example, when we review that heat treatment requirement as Carbon equivalent method as per BS 2642, we can find that Heat treatment may be required for ASTM A387-Gr.11-Cl.2, because carbon contents is of 0.57% according to below formula.
Carbon equivalent (As per BS 2642)=
C(0.13%)+Mn(0.49%)/6+Cr(1.3%)+Mo(0.52%)/5+Ni(0.02%)+Cu(0.02%)/15=0.57%
When carbon equivalent value is more than 0.45%, pre-heating and post-heating treatment should be performed. However, the problem is that carbon equivalent method also can not be covered every metallurgy condition as mentioned before.

7. CONCLUSION
Mostly welding crack occurs from starting stress increasing between solid solution for each grain boundary of Cr, Carbon, we call this as integranular stress, and this is no more growing after cooling down but stress is remaining.
the best method is doing stress relieving with heat treatment, However, this stress
can be removed during equipment operation in high temperature service.
We call this as stress relieving with Creep stress, normally Creep is defined
as stress strain due to high temperature and regular frequency stress because
this Creep moving grain boundary gradually during operation.
Therefore, when we"re doing welding in a not confined area and even Cr-Mo, Low-Alloy material, it is not necessary to do heat treatment and moreover, if that is 2"ND boundary of pressure parts, no need to do heat treatment if welding qualify is to be verified with NDE test after welding.

Moreover, when it be performed with local heat treatment because of any reason
It can not be avoid heating gradient at heating boundary as we called "heating soak band" This heating soak band is similar to heat affect zone(HAZ) at welding, occurs 475 oC embrittlement. Therefore, the best way to stress relieving method is to do furnance heat treatment. If heating and cooling temperature can not be strictly controlled. -The End---

* 원문은 피이에스엔지니어링 자료실에 있음.
http://www.pes21.com/home_56/room_solution/dataroom.ASP

2012.07.25
기술사 류창명/건설기계기술사/산업기계설비기술사
wine@pes21.com
http://www.pes21.com
[답변]          [삭제]

No.

제  목

글쓴이

날짜

조회

15

 Comparing Low-Alloy Vs ...

운영자

2014-01-29

257519